Sari la conținut
Flickerfield

Toate postările

The engine26 august 2026 · 3 min de citit

Screen or torch: two ways to flicker a phone

The rear LED is brighter. The display has colour, duty cycle and exact timing. Neither choice is wrong, and here is the whole trade in one place.

There are exactly two sources of controllable light on a phone: the display and the camera flash LED on the back. Apps in this category pick one, and the pick determines almost everything else about the product. This post is the fair version of the comparison, including the parts where the torch wins.

What the torch gives you

Brightness, by a wide margin. A camera flash LED is built to light a room from several metres away. Against a closed eyelid at arm's length it is enormously brighter than a phone screen at full white. Brightness matters here: the light has to get through the eyelid, and eyelids differ in thickness and blood content from person to person.

Consistency across devices. A flash LED is a flash LED. Screen technology varies far more: OLED and LCD behave differently, panels have different peak brightness, some dim themselves when they get warm.

Positioning freedom. The phone can sit face-down on a table with the torch pointing up at you, which some people find more comfortable than balancing a screen.

Those are real advantages and it would be dishonest to skip them. If raw intensity through the eyelid is what you want, the torch is the better instrument.

What the torch costs you

Colour. The flash LED is white, or white with a warm-tinted second LED. There is no red, no amber, no blue. Every session looks the same.

Duty cycle. A camera LED is driven by the camera subsystem, through an API designed for photography rather than for a waveform. You can turn it on and off; you cannot reliably ask for "on for 20% of a 100 ms cycle" across the whole fleet of Android and iOS devices.

Timing. The torch switch is not tied to the display's frame clock. The request goes through the camera stack, which has its own latency and its own ideas about scheduling. For a stimulus where the regularity of the interval is part of what is being studied, that is the wrong bus to be on.

Heat and battery. Running a flash LED at high duty for ten minutes makes the phone hot enough to throttle. Thermal throttling changes timing, which brings you back to the previous point, and a hot phone is unpleasant to hold against your face.

What the screen gives you

Exact frequencies. The display's frame callback is the same clock the flicker is derived from, so a frequency that divides the refresh rate is produced exactly, and the app can tell you when your chosen frequency does not divide.

Colour, per segment. Red at 7.5 Hz. Amber at 10. A slow walk from violet to blue across a twelve-minute program. This is not decoration: colour is a variable people report as making a noticeable difference to what they see, and the library uses it as one.

Duty cycle from 0.1 to 0.9. The proportion of each cycle that is lit, adjustable, meaning the same thing at every frequency.

Multi-segment programs. Ramps, holds, oscillations and colour changes that hold their shape for fifteen minutes, because everything is derived from one continuous phase value rather than restarted at each step.

A cool phone and a slower battery drain. A display at moderate brightness is a much lighter load than a flash LED at high duty.

The honest summary

ScreenTorch
Brightness through the eyelidLowerMuch higher
ColourFull RGBWhite only
Duty cycle control0.1–0.9Effectively none
Timing sourceDisplay frame clockCamera subsystem
HeatLowHigh
BatteryModerateHeavy
Device consistencyVaries by panelVery consistent

The trade is brightness for control. This app takes control, which is a choice rather than a verdict; it also supports the torch, and both at once, because some people simply want the brighter light and should be able to have it.

One thing does not vary between the two: both are flashing light in a frequency range that can provoke a seizure in people with photosensitive epilepsy. The exclusions on the safety page apply identically to both, and a dimmer screen is not a safer option for anyone on that list. It is the same answer either way: if you are on that list, use neither.

Referințe

  1. Apple Developer documentation: CADisplayLink
  2. Android Developers reference: CameraManager (torch mode)
  3. Amaya et al. (2023), effect of flicker frequency and rhythmicity, PLOS ONE 18(4): e0284271